Eleanor’s Story: A New Prescription, A New Kind of Confusion

Eleanor had lived with Alzheimer’s disease for three years. Her days followed a rhythm her daughter, Marie, had learned to trust: breakfast at seven, a walk around the yard, a nap after lunch, and quiet evenings with the television turned low. Nothing dramatic. Nothing scary. Just the slow, steady fade that comes with the disease.

Then Eleanor’s primary care provider added an antidepressant. She had seemed withdrawn at her last visit, staring out the window more than usual, answering questions with a single word. The provider called it depression. Fifteen minutes later, a prescription was in hand, and Marie was told to watch for “the usual side effects.”

Nobody mentioned what those side effects might look like on top of dementia. Nobody asked what other medications Eleanor was already taking. Nobody checked.

Within nine days, Eleanor stopped sleeping through the night. She paced. Her hands trembled in a way Marie had never seen. Her heart raced so hard that Marie could see her pulse in her neck from across the room. By day eleven, Eleanor’s temperature spiked to 102 degrees, and her muscles twitched involuntarily, even at rest.

The emergency room doctor asked one question that changed everything: “What new medications has she started in the last two weeks?” A pharmacist reviewing the chart connected the dots within minutes. Eleanor already took a muscle relaxant for restless legs. That drug, combined with the new antidepressant, had pushed her serotonin levels into dangerous territory. She had serotonin syndrome.

Marie had trusted the process. She had trusted the fifteen-minute appointment, the printed prescription, and the assumption that someone, somewhere, had checked for this. Nobody had.

Why Dementia Changes the Math on Drug Interactions

Eleanor’s story is not rare, and it is not exaggerated. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Directors Association tracked more than 485,000 Medicare nursing home residents and found that people with Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias experienced drug-drug interactions more often, and those interactions lasted longer, than in residents without dementia. Across the full study population, 56.6% of residents were exposed to at least one potentially dangerous drug combination during their stay.

Residents with dementia showed a rate 4.7 percentage points higher than residents without dementia, even after researchers adjusted for age, sex, and how sick each person already was. Scale that up across the roughly 1.2 million nursing home residents living in the United States today, and the researchers estimated nearly 40,000 additional people with dementia are exposed to a dangerous drug pairing that would not have happened, statistically, if they did not have dementia.

One of the three most common interaction types identified in that research is: A selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor, the antidepressant class Eleanor was prescribed, combined with another serotonin-affecting drug, including something as ordinary as tramadol for pain. This is not a hidden or exotic risk. It sits in plain sight, in combinations prescribed every single day.

A separate study published in JAMA, led by researchers at the University of Michigan, looked at 1.2 million people with dementia living outside nursing homes. Researchers found that 13.9% of them were taking three or more medications that act on the brain and central nervous system for more than a month at a time, a pattern researchers call CNS-active polypharmacy. Among that group, 92% were taking an antidepressant, and 41% were taking a benzodiazepine. Dementia does not lower the number of medications a person needs. It raises the stakes attached to every single one.

The Chemical Imbalance Myth and Why It Still Gets People Hurt

For decades, patients heard a simple explanation for depression: a chemical imbalance in the brain, correctable with medication, the way insulin corrects blood sugar. That explanation was never proven. A comprehensive review of the research found no consistent evidence that depression results from low serotonin or any other single chemical imbalance.

This matters. It matters for every family member sitting across from a provider, nodding along as a new antidepressant gets prescribed for a loved one with dementia who seems withdrawn, tearful, or apathetic.

Depression and anxiety are real. Suffering is real. But when a provider still explains prescribing decisions using a theory the research does not support, that provider is working from an outdated script rather than current evidence. And an outdated script, applied to a person whose brain is already changing because of dementia, does not just fail to help. It can actively hurt, particularly when it opens the door to a medication that interacts badly with something else already in the cabinet.

Eleanor’s provider was not a villain. Fifteen-minute visits do not allow for a thorough review of pharmacology, and providers are stretched across dozens of patients a day. But that time crunch is exactly why families cannot afford to assume the science has already been checked on their behalf.

Serotonin Syndrome: What It Looks Like and Why It Matters

Serotonin syndrome happens when serotonin builds up to dangerous levels in the body, usually from combining two or more medications that each raise serotonin activity. It moves fast. It can start within hours of a new dose and worsen within days, exactly as it did for Eleanor.

Watch for these signs:

  • Agitation, restlessness, or sudden confusion that seems disconnected from the person’s usual dementia symptoms
  • A racing heartbeat or a noticeable rise in blood pressure
  • A high fever, sometimes climbing above 101 or 102 degrees, without any sign of infection
  • Muscle twitching, rigidity, or tremors, especially in the legs
  • In severe, untreated cases, seizures

That last item on the list is not a routine side effect. It is a medical emergency. If a loved one with dementia starts a new antidepressant, anti-anxiety medication, or pain medication and any of these signs appear, that is not the time to wait for the next scheduled appointment. That is a call to the prescriber or a trip to urgent care, the same day.

Benzodiazepines, Antidepressants, and the Mortality Risk No One Mentions

Here is something many families do not realize: several of the same medications used to treat anxiety are chemically and functionally close cousins of antidepressants, and benzodiazepines specifically carry a documented mortality risk in people with dementia. Drugs like lorazepam, alprazolam, and diazepam calm agitation quickly, which makes them tempting for a provider facing a distressed patient and an anxious family in a short appointment.

But the evidence on long-term use in dementia points the other way. These drugs increase fall risk, increase the risk of confusion and delirium, and are linked to higher mortality in older adults with cognitive impairment. The Michigan Medicine research found benzodiazepines present in 41% of the community-dwelling dementia patients already flagged for risky CNS-active polypharmacy, a group whose combination of drugs “goes beyond the limits recommended by the internationally accepted guidelines called the Beers criteria.”

This is not a reason to panic if a loved one already takes one of these medications. It is a reason to stop assuming that the prescription pad automatically came with a full risk assessment attached. A caregiver who says “the doctor prescribed it, so it must be fine” is placing enormous trust in a system that, as Eleanor’s story shows, does not always catch what it should. Advocacy is not distrust of the provider. It is a partnership, one where the caregiver asks the questions the fifteen-minute visit did not have time to cover.

Two Kinds of Medication Review: The Quick Check and the Real Thing

Most families have sat through a version of medication review that looks like this: a nurse or medical assistant reads down a list on a clipboard or a screen. “Still on your blood pressure pill? Still taking the same dose of your sleep medicine? Good, moving on.” It takes less than a minute. A box gets checked in the chart. The visit note says medications were reviewed.

That is not a review. That is inventory.

What HappensQuick Check (Office, ER, Urgent Care)Comprehensive Review (Health Navigator, Pharmacist Consult)
Time spentUnder two minutes, often folded into a busy visitThirty minutes to an hour, dedicated entirely to medications
What gets checkedWhat the person takes and how oftenWhy each drug is prescribed, whether it still serves a purpose, and how it interacts with everything else
Interaction screeningRarely cross-checked against a full interaction databaseChecked against tools like the Beers Criteria and STOPP-FRAIL
Cognitive risk considerationAlmost never addressed directlyCentral to the review, especially for anticholinergic and CNS-active drugs
Family involvementLimited to answering yes or noDirect conversation about symptoms, patterns, and goals of care

A genuine, comprehensive medication reconciliation asks harder questions than any quick check ever will. Is this drug still doing what it was meant to do? Has a side effect built up slowly enough that nobody connected it to the pill? Does the combination, taken as a whole, raise red flags under recognized safety tools that a fifteen-minute visit rarely has time to consult?

What a Real Review Catches That a Quick Check Misses

Consider Harold, a 92-year-old man living at home with congestive heart failure and diabetes, taking twelve medications at once. A comprehensive review conducted by Peter Abraham, BSN, RN, of Compassion Crossing, LLC, examined every prescription line by line, weighing the actual benefit of each drug against its risks for Harold’s age and stage of illness.

The review recommended discontinuing his high-dose statin entirely, since its cardiovascular benefit at his age was estimated at only 2 to 3% over five years while it raised his fall risk. It recommended stopping his daily aspirin, since the bleeding risk at 92 outweighed a stroke reduction benefit measured at just 0.3%. It recommended tapering off a stomach acid reducer he had taken for years without anyone reassessing whether he still needed it, and it flagged his nightly melatonin as an unnecessary fall risk that could be reduced or dropped altogether.

None of that surfaced during Harold’s regular office visits. Every single medication had been “reviewed” at every appointment, in the sense that someone had read the list aloud and confirmed he was still taking it. Nobody had asked whether he should still be taking it.

How Often Should a Loved One’s Medications Be Reviewed?

Genuine medication review does not happen automatically, nor does it happen on a schedule anyone sets by default. Someone has to request it, and the right frequency depends heavily on how healthy your loved one is right now.

For a generally healthy older adult not managing a chronic illness, tie the review to something familiar: the rhythm of an eye exam. Once a year, or at minimum once every two years, sit down with a pharmacist or provider and go through the full list, asking whether each medication still earns its place.

For someone managing a chronic condition such as heart failure, diabetes, or COPD, the review needs to happen far more often. Request one anytime a new medication gets added or an existing one changes dose, and build in a standing check at least every three to six months even when nothing has changed on paper, because the body managing a chronic illness changes even when the prescription list does not.

For someone who is terminally ill, the frequency tightens again. Request a review whenever their condition takes a downward turn, whenever any medication is added, removed, or adjusted, and at least once a month, regardless of whether anything else has shifted. A body in decline processes medication differently week to week, and what was safe last month may not be safe now.

You Are Allowed to Ask Questions

Marie did not know she was allowed to ask her mother’s provider whether a new antidepressant had been checked against Eleanor’s existing medications. She assumed that step had already happened, quietly, behind the scenes. It had not.

You are allowed to ask. You are allowed to request a real, sit-down medication review from your pharmacist, who often has more specialized training in medication interactions than a general practice provider and more time to dedicate to the conversation. You are allowed to ask your loved one’s provider directly whether a proposed new medication has been checked against everything else currently being taken, and whether the provider is familiar with current research questioning the chemical imbalance explanation for depression before that prescription gets written.

And if you want a dedicated set of eyes on the full picture, someone whose entire focus for that hour is your loved one’s medication list and nothing else, Peter Abraham, BSN, RN, at Compassion Crossing, LLC, offers exactly that kind of independent, comprehensive review.

Eleanor recovered. The antidepressant was stopped, the muscle relaxant was adjusted, and within a week her fever broke, and her tremors faded. Marie still thinks about how close it came, and how a fifteen-second conversation instead of a fifteen-minute one might have caught it before it ever reached the emergency room. You do not have to wait for a crisis to ask the question Marie wishes she had asked sooner. Ask it today, this week, at the next appointment. Your loved one’s safety should never depend on the hope that someone else has already checked.

Resources

Study: Residents with Alzheimer’s experience more frequent, longer drug-drug interactions

Drug-Drug Interactions in Nursing Home Residents With vs Without Dementia

Troubling Trio: Many with Dementia Take Risky Combinations of Medicines

Depression Is Not Caused by Chemical Imbalance in the Brain

Understanding Dementia Medication Side Effects: A Guide for Families

Understanding Medication Risks in Hospice Dementia Care: A Guide for Families and Healthcare Teams

Understanding Serotonin Syndrome

Self-paced Dementia Training Courses, including Dementia Staging Made Understandable: A Family Guide to Using the FAST Scale

Free Caregiver and Dementia Training Videos

How to read and apply the FAST Scale to stage any type of dementia. Dementia Staging Made Easy (YouTube)

This site uses Amazon Associate links, which means I earn a small commission when you purchase books or products through these links—at no extra cost to you. These earnings help me keep this website running and ad-free, so I can continue providing helpful articles and resources at no charge.

If you don’t see anything you need today but still want to support this work, you can buy me a cup of coffee or tea. Every bit of support helps me continue writing and sharing resources for families during difficult times.

The 36-Hour Day: A Family Guide to Caring for People Who Have Alzheimer’s Disease and Other Dementias

Creating Moments of Joy Along the Alzheimer’s Journey: A Guide for Families and Caregivers, Fifth Edition, Revised and Expanded

Geri-Gadgets – Washable, sensory tools that calm, focus, and connect—at any age, in any setting

Caregiver Support Book Series

Dementia Caregiver Essentials: Comprehensive Guide for Dementia Care (one book that contains the ten books below for less than one-third the price of all ten)

The Validation Breakthrough: Simple Techniques for Communicating with People with ‘Alzheimer’s-Type Dementia’

Dementia Home Care: How to Prepare Before, During, and After

DEMENTIA DENIED: One Woman’s True Story of Surviving a Terminal Diagnosis & Reclaiming Her Life

Atypical Dementias: Understanding Mid-Life Language, Visual, Behavioral, and Cognitive Changes

The Dementia Caregiver’s Survival Guide: An 11-Step Plan to Understand the Disease and How To Cope with Financial Challenges, Patient Aggression, and Depression Without Guilt, Overwhelm, or Burnout

Fading Reflection: Understanding the complexities of Dementia

Dementia Caregiving: A Self Help Book for Dementia Caregivers Offering Practical Coping Strategies and Support to Overcome Burnout, Increase Awareness, and Build Mental & Emotional Resilience

Navigating the Dementia Journey: A Compassionate Guide to Understanding, Supporting, and Living With Dementia

Ahead of Dementia: A Real-World, Upfront, Straightforward, Step-by-Step Guide for Family Caregivers

Four Common Mistakes by Caregivers of Loved Ones with Dementia and What Do Differently (video)

The National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys (NAELA) is dedicated to improving the quality of legal services provided to older adults and people with disabilities

Articles on Advance Directives

Eldercare Locator: a nationwide service that connects older Americans and their caregivers with trustworthy local support resources

Find the Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program in Your State

Greater National Advocates Directory of Independent Patient Advocates

Patients Voices Matter Foundation – Empowering Patients, Transforming Lives

Independent Patient Advocate – Independent, non-clinical patient advocacy nationwide. Health Navigation, SSDI Application & Appeals, and Whole Health Advocacy. 100% remote. No insurance accepted.

Compassion Crossing, LLC – Independent, clinical patient advocacy nationwide.

Natural Death With Dignity: Protecting Your Right To Refuse Medical Treatment

Beyond the Living Will: Creating Effective Advance Directives and Value-Based Advance Care Planning: A Guide for Helping Professionals

Make Your Own Medical & Financial Power of Attorney: A Step-By-Step Guide to Making a Power of Attorney

Last things first, just in case… The Practical Guide to Living Wills and Durable Powers of Attorney for Health Care

Death and Dying: A Good Exit Plan

Free Daily Symptom Tracker: Each headache, flare, or fatigue spike reveals a clue. This two-page Daily Symptom Tracker records sleep quality, food intake, triggers, severity, and effective relief methods—all in one place. Use it daily for 31 days and share the pages with your healthcare provider or health navigation expert. Together, you can move from guessing to addressing the root cause. Instructions on how to use the free daily symptom tracker and the free daily symptom tracker.

Free Caregiver and Dementia Training Videos

CaringInfo – Caregiver support and much more!

The Hospice Care Plan (guide) and The Hospice Care Plan (video series)

Understanding Palliative Care: A Guide to Common Questions and Answers

Bridging the Gap: Palliative Care’s Role in Supporting Rare Disease Patients

Comprehensive Guide to Financial Assistance for Hospice and Palliative Care Patients

Surviving Caregiving with Dignity, Love, and Kindness

Caregivers.com | Simplifying the Search for In-Home Care

Geri-Gadgets – Washable, sensory tools that calm, focus, and connect—at any age, in any setting

Healing Through Grief and Loss: A Christian Journey of Integration and Recovery

This site uses Amazon Associate links, which means I earn a small commission when you purchase books or products through these links—at no extra cost to you. These earnings help me keep this website running and ad-free, so I can continue providing helpful articles and resources at no charge.

If you don’t see anything you need today but still want to support this work, you can buy me a cup of coffee or tea. Every bit of support helps me continue writing and sharing resources for families during difficult times.

Caregiver Support Book Series

VSED Support: What Friends and Family Need to Know

My Aging Parent Needs Help!: 7-Step Guide to Caregiving with No Regrets, More Compassion, and Going from Overwhelmed to Organized [Includes Tips for Caregiver Burnout]

Take Back Your Life: A Caregiver’s Guide to Finding Freedom in the Midst of Overwhelm

The Conscious Caregiver: A Mindful Approach to Caring for Your Loved One Without Losing Yourself

Dear Caregiver, It’s Your Life Too: 71 Self-Care Tips To Manage Stress, Avoid Burnout, And Find Joy Again While Caring For A Loved One

Everything Happens for a Reason: And Other Lies I’ve Loved

The Art of Dying

Final Gifts: Understanding the Special Awareness, Needs, and Communications of the Dying

Share your love

Newsletter Updates

Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter